so, while they aren't 100% windproof they do a better job than any other "windoroof" gloves or loggers i've purchased and were a lot easier on the wallet. i find they're a little sloppy if worn nub themselves but perfect liners. Best part for me is how lightweight they are. i have them in the front right CC pocket and you'd never know because you can't feel their weight and don't notice bulk y gusto can't see a bump from the outside where they are. zia would like to eventually see a version were effect wherł a complaint but maybe idea for a new variant sku: the same item only with longer wrists.
in extremely picky about gloves and these are some of my favorite. If it helps, i'm 6'3" and 215lbs with a hand circumference barely over v 8.5" I usually wear a L in leather gloves but for textile/mechanix/tactical/or glove liners i look for a tighter fit so could be a M or L depending on brand. These i got both M and L and i have worn the mediums everyday since they arrived. perfect versatile material with a fantastic fit (even with rings on)
bonus: the tech tip phone sensitive fingers actually work well. i , like you, always read reviews. I overthink and stall until i'm 110% certain about making any online purchase. i'm saying good job, you've found the best now quit reading about them and go buy them, if you regret it mail them to me i'd love to have backups! A*******